Today, I'm delighted to welcome Justin Ordonez, the author of Sykosa to the blog with a fantastic guest post about a male author writing a teenage girl. Really interesting. I hope you all enjoy it.
Cross-Gender
Writing Sucks; Now Let’s All Do It Anyway
Writing teenage girls sucks, and it sucks because it’s difficult. We
all know the over worn clichés about women’s emotions, menstruation, driving,
and rabid shopping. I’m not here to relive those. I’m here to state a truth
about writing characters. It’s that while, in general, women are hard to fully
form in the written word, the hardest subgroup is teenage girls. Nothing’s
harder to get right, and—this is a big “and”—nothing’s easier to bomb. Alicia Silverstone
described this dilemma better than I ever could, when she surmised the best
teenage girl move ever Clueless.
“I think that
Clueless was very deep. I think it was deep in the way that it was very light.
I think lightness has to come from a very deep place if it is true
lightness."
Silverstone was
chastised for this statement, attacked for being an airhead and awarded the
“Foot in the Mouth Award” for “Most Baffling Statement” in 2000. Here’s the
thing, though. If you can’t understand Alicia’s words, and not only understand
her, but live it, think it, philosophize it, and build a lifestyle around it,
you have no business writing teenage girls. Because here’s what you probably
won’t believe, Alicia’s statement is 100% correct, and it’s not only 100%
correct, it makes 100% perfect sense, and no one will ever speak on this
subject more clairvoyantly or poignantly than Alicia did.
So what did Alicia
mean?
Let me do a little
trick us writers like to refer to as “storytelling.”
Being 29, I don’t spend
time with teenage girls, as doing so would be disturbing. Not all writers feel
this way. In order to properly understand the motivations of his heroes and
heroines, author Tom Wolfe went deep undercover for his book I Am Charlotte Simmons, making his way
across college campuses to familiarize himself with the modern flavor of youth.
I suppose you can admire this dedication, but only if you can somehow overlook
how, between finding sixty different ways to modify your name so the word
“Viagra” is in it, you’re gonna get nicknames like, “Old Dumb Short Bald Dude”
and, “The Pervert Grandpa,” assigned to you, and the best joke everyone’s gonna
retell for decades is the time when, [enter name here], the sweet, innocent,
gullible girl of the group broke into hysterical crying after being asked to
envision your old, droopy balls.
Straight up player.
I don’t know about
you, but there’s no way I could do it.
Look, I believe in
authentic writing, I do, and think it is important to do some character study. I
also like having my pride, so I know, being not entirely old myself, to stay
away from these kids at all costs. They’re young, they’re good looking (even
the bad looking ones), they think they’re never going to die, and years of
education across a multitude of subjects has made them moderately proficient at
most topics, so they can embarrass you academically even though, in reality,
they don’t know anything and would crawl up into the corner, crying and sucking
their thumb at their first encounter with one of life’s big, adult challenges!
(Or so I tell
myself desperately every night before I go to sleep).
“I’m still young. I’m still young. I’m
still young. I’m still young.”
You need to get
inspiration another way.
And by “you,” I
mean, “me.”
Sometimes, life
just obliges.
It’s May 2011.
Sykosa—my forthcoming novel—isn’t
finished. In fact, I’m a bit lost. I know I’m close to finishing it, but how
long it will take to finish “close” could be three weeks or three years. I need
a holiday badly. I’m about to get one. My sister lives in New York,
specifically in the Lower East Side of Manhattan, which is a happening place
since Lady Gaga lived there before going megastar. It’s a little neighborhood
neighboring the more well known Greenwich Village, and it’s full of old
buildings and young, spirited, unconsciously sexy people. My sister shares an
apartment, which probably violates every zoning code in any city of America but
New York, and being the size of a 1 bedroom apartment, and once again it being the
city of New York, she shares it with a friend from her college days. Being the
room mate introduction, it’s nothing fancy. I meet her after she comes from
work, my sister and I relaxing after touring Grand Central Station. Being a
writer, I can tell instantly I’ve changed their dynamic. While my sister and
her friend want to make me feel welcome, it’s clear their routine after work is
to drink wine and banter about who’s hooking up with whom, who wants to get
married, who is scared to get married, who just needs to get their stuff
together, and while they try to include me, the more time passes, the more they
divulge into side conversations about their lives and circumstances.
This might be
boring for me, but something keeps coming up.
Let’s see if you can
identify it.
“Did you hear that
so and so… Awkward turtle!” – “Oh, my God, I heard that! That was so Awkward
Turtle!” – “Was it like the time…? You remember when…? Awkward Turtle!” –
“That’s so crazy. It’s so Awkward Turtle whenever they’re around.”
Awkward Turtle.
Now, I’ve listened
to this conversation patiently, expecting that, given a certain number of
examples, its definition will become contextually obvious. It doesn’t happen.
Eventually, I have to stop them, and I do. At the edge of the couch, I say, “I
have to know, what exactly is…” And in the most serious, least humiliating way
I can think to do it, and this is difficult considering I’m 6’4”, 230lbs, and I
have the frame and a look that once inspired a random stranger to spontaneously
shout, “You look like one of those assholes who rows crew at Harvard,” I put my
thumbs at my forehead, extending my fingers like they were antlers, but bent so
my fingertips touch fingertips, making a somewhat lazy triangle, and say,
“Awkward Turtle?”
Wait a second… I’m reconsidering this whole
“crew” thing.
What results is the
kind of laughing that almost lacks reason. Like spectacle laughing—what
happened isn’t even funny, it’s just laughing because that’s what you do when
you see the asshole who rows crew at Harvard being an asshole or something. You
laugh. The problem is its become contagious between my sister and her friend,
as they croak and spit, each failing to reenact my too serious impersonation
while assuring me, “I swear,” LOL LOL LOL HAHAHAHAHAHA! “We’re not laughing”
LMAO! LMAO! LOL! HAHAHAHAHA!!! “At you—I swear, I swear!” Which becomes ever
less likely as their faces turn ghostly white, and their eyes go empty, having
laughed so hard they’ve dislodged their aortas, turning their insides into spinning
lawn sprinklers of internal hemorrhaging and poetic justice!
(I may have
imagined that last part).
Once the hilarity
settles, an explanation comes. Apparently, “Awkward Turtle” is only one
designation of what is a multi-leveled, hierarchically ordered classification
system built to assign value to the severity of life’s awkward moments.
That’s not a joke.
That’s what it is.
The dorks have a
methodology to the whole thing.
(I have to call
them dorks. They laughed at me for, like, five minutes).
Basically, a level
of awkwardness is given an animal designation that’s paired with a hand signal
at your forehead. If you’re awkwardness wasn’t too weird, it’s “Awkward Kitty.”
A little worse? You get the most commonly designated one. “Awkward Turtle.” Something
extremely awkward? “Awkward Shark.” Something even worse? “Awkward
Hippopotamus.” What’s the top level? What’s reserved only for the type of
awkwardness so bad that all social graces fail and you’ve frozen everyone in
your immediate vicinity in such shock they may be contemplating whether or not
spontaneous combustion is the best option for you? “Awkward Hippopotamus Out of
the Water.” None of this makes sense, but my sister, who cannot stop laughing,
looks at me like, what’s the matter with
you, don’t you get it? and says,
“Have you ever seen a hippopotamus out of the water? It’s looks so awkward and
uncomfortable!”
They look fine to me…
What’s my point of
this story?
I’m glad you asked.
My sister works for
one of the largest consulting firms in the world. Her friend works for a major
pharmaceutical company. Sure, they’re acting girlish, but it’s temporary, and
when the time comes, they’ve got serious jobs and serious
responsibilities—things giving them depth, character, arches, and these things
make women like my sister and her friend easier to write than five years
before, when they were making these stupid jokes, but had no jobs, no steady
boyfriends, no place of their own or even cars. Yet, at the time five years
ago, my sister and her friend were full of as much depth, as much character,
and as many arches. Without the easy to navigate, agreed upon identities of the
adult world, how would someone know how to draw those out? How would you
construct metaphors, analogies, and have them be ones that weren’t condescending
and pretentious?
To this we turn to
Alicia Silverstone.
“I think that
Clueless was very deep. I think it was deep in the way that it was very light.
I think lightness has to come from a very deep place if it is true lightness."
Clairvoyant?
In order to draw
meaning from young female protagonists, we need to look to their lightness to
understand their depth, and if we do this, the depth we will discover will feel
genuine to both the writer and reader. You need to ignore the fact that my
sister and her friend were laughing at me and focus on the joyfulness of the
laughter itself, then focus not on my sister’s explanation of, “Have you ever
seen a hippopotamus out of the water?” and pay attention to the look she gave me,
the, what’s the matter with you, don’t
you get it? glare. In this lies the soul, purpose and heart of young women,
especially teenage women, and this lives in us all from time to time, place to
place, and it does not in anyway require—to the disappointment of male writers
the world over—hanging out with, getting to know, or secretly hoping you score
nineteen year old coeds.
The older we get,
the more we become “adults,” “professionals,” “men and women,” “husband and
wives,” “fathers and mothers.” We accept these labels and wear them like badges
of honor. They become a mantra we bring into our work places, our social
circles, and the voting booth. Unfortunately, with each passing day, we forget,
and we lose, part of that lightness—that place where identity is
self-determined, and drawn from the metaphysical thing which happens when
you’re around people you really love, like all-out love. Some of us hang onto
some of it, many of us vaguely recall it, lots of us surrender totally and
pathetically to what can easily and ironically be described as the child-like,
vapid pool of adult decision making. Of this we must all be careful, and if
you’re a writer even moreso, because before you realize it, you’re not only not understanding what Awkward Turtle
is, but you’re so embarrassed you’re not even bothering to ask, and instead of
engaging and learning about the world, you’re smugly handing out an award about
how it’s the Most Baffling Statement of 2012, all so you can, in the most vain
of vain attempts, feel better about yourself—and it’ll work, you will feel
better about yourself, and you’ll feel certain of your place in this world, but
go back and look at your writing, really look at it and dissect it and question
it…
What do you feel
now?
Hey!
Justin Ordoñez wrote a book called Sykosa. It’s about a sixteen year old girl
who’s trying to reclaim her identity after an act of violence destroys her life
and the lives of her friends. You can find out more about Justin at his blog, http://sykosa.wordpress.com. You can
also find Sykosa, the novel on Amazon. http://www.amazon.com/dp/B007N709IG/
1 Comentário:
Suzanne, thanks so much for hosting Justin today. What a great post based on an Alicia Silverstone quote - "Clueless" fans unite! Also love the pic and caption of Tom Wolfe - hilarious :)
Post a Comment
I love to read all your comments so please feel free to post.
This is an award and tag free blog.